Family care needs aren’t just occasional. Many employees are ongoing caregivers for children, parents, or other relatives. When support falls short, stress rises and PTO gets stretched. So why does backup care break down, and how can employers fix it?

This was the topic of discussion at a From Day One webinar titled, “The Employees You Don’t Hear From: Why Backup Care Breaks Down at Work,” led by Jess Brown, vice president of marketing for Cariloop.

Employers are turning to solutions such as Cariloop, an employer-sponsored caregiving benefit that helps to provide solutions for working parents and caregivers, and other avenues that help caregiving employees with their multifaceted needs. 

Caregiving Support Issues

Dee Brown, TV personality, freelance reporter, and session moderator, stated that the system isn’t working the way that we had hoped it would. “73% of the workforce is caring for someone and nearly half say finding last minute care is very difficult. Additionally, 48% of employers offer caregiving support but only 36% offer backup child care,” said Dee Brown. As a caregiver, she can relate to the need for caregiving options all too well.  

The state of caregiving is a multifaceted problem and system under intense pressure due to an increased demand and lessened supply, says Jess Brown. She stated there are two types of caregiving supply including family caregivers and professional caregivers. Family caregivers are individuals caring for their family members and this has a direct impact on employment as these individuals are often pursuing a full-time job while handling caregiving duties. Professional caregivers for adult care have been facing shortages and 48 states have reported shortages, according to AARP.  “More professionals are leaving the field than are entering the field,” said Jess Brown. 

“The good news is that data is showing us that new licensed child care centers are slowly coming back and rebuilding a little bit year over year,” said Jess Brown. 

However, waitlists are an issue for parents seeking child care centers and there is an average of 6 months to 2 years on a waitlist. In addition, the cost issue is problematic as well since higher demand than supply equals higher cost, she says.

Beyond caring for children, many people aren’t prepared to care for aging parents, making it a daunting responsibility that employers should take seriously.

There have been changes in workforce participation in the past few years, says Jess Brown. Women’s workforce participation rates have reduced whereas men’s have started to slightly increase. This may be due to women opting out of the workforce or not being able to work due to caregiving duties.

Employers should pay close attention to employees’ caregiving responsibilities, as added stress can impact productivity and drive costs tied to absenteeism and turnover. Care demands can lead to leaves of absence, burnout, mental health challenges, and exhaustion.

There are also early signs of backup care breaking down. Employees dealing with issues at home may be distracted at work and more prone to burnout. More visible signals include missed work, increased claims related to family needs, and employees leaving the workforce altogether, says Jess Brown.

Why Caregiving Support Benefits Matter 

There are three core areas of caregiving benefits. The first is backup care, an employer-subsidized benefit that provides temporary solutions when regular care falls through, helping reduce unplanned time away from work. The second is caregiver support, which addresses broader challenges across all life stages, from navigating a parent’s new health diagnosis to finding child care. Lastly, caregiving benefits can include access to discounts and resources, such as marketplaces and child care centers.

Traditional backup care models often fall short because, while they help employees search for care, supply is limited, says Jess Brown. The provider networks employers select may also not meet the specific needs of employees and their families. In addition, she said, “we need to invest in programs where 100% of the dollars allocated to sponsoring caregiving costs go directly to the care provider.”

Return on investment is an important consideration with caregiving benefits. It includes soft ROI, such as reducing stress that can lead to health issues for employees, and hard ROI, such as measurable improvements in clinical outcomes. Dollar-for-dollar savings should also be part of the equation, says Jess Brown.

As for how employers should get started considering the impact of caregiving benefits, they can compare leave claims between those who used caregiving benefits and those who didn’t. Survey data can also be consulted to come up with information regarding caregiving benefits and unplanned leave. The best way for employers to evaluate new or updated caregiving programs is to take advantage of their benefit consultants and ask the right questions regarding planned investments and desired returns.

Providing the Benefits That Matter Most

When asked how these benefits can be used when they matter most, Jess Brown emphasized the need for strong promotion. Employees can’t use programs they don’t know about, and access must be quick and seamless.

For organizations new to caregiving benefits, impact can be measured through cost savings if a program is already in place, or by tracking reductions in missed work if one is not. Surveys and year-over-year analysis can also provide insight, she says. Companies that get these programs right tend to see stronger retention. Success often comes from refining offerings to fit both employee needs and budget, sometimes even resulting in cost savings.

Jess Brown also noted a disconnect that can exist between the care networks offered and what’s actually available or comfortable for employees to use. In some cases, people don’t even identify themselves as caregivers, which limits uptake.

Finally, she stressed that caregiving challenges aren’t solved overnight. Employers need to invest in support and be patient in seeing results. Employee sentiment can be tracked through engagement surveys and qualitative feedback, alongside honest, transparent communication.

Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Cariloop, for sponsoring this webinar. 

Kristen Kwiatkowski is a professional freelance writer covering a wide array of industries, with a focus on food and beverage and business. Her work has been featured in the Bucks County Herald, Eater Philly, Edible Lehigh Valley, Cider Culture, and The Town Dish.

(Photo by jacoblund/iStock)